About Us

Homemade Ice Cream Cakes

Call to order.

A variety of cakes are always in the store ready for take out!

Standard cakes are made with a layer of chocolate ice cream covered with chocolate cake crunch topped with a layer of vanilla ice cream then iced with whipped topping.

Create a Custom Cake by choosing any 2 flavors of your choice, hard ice cream, hard yogurt, or no-sugar-added ice cream.

Kelly’s makes a supreme cake called a Neapolitan with 3 delicious layers of homemade ice cream. Traditional Neapolitan has a layer of chocolate ice cream with chocolate cake crunch topped with a layer of strawberry ice cream with another layer of chocolate cake crunch topped with vanilla ice cream and iced with whipped topping.

Try a Kelly’s Brownie Cake by swapping out the chocolate cake crunch for a brownie and fudge in the center a really special treat! YUM!

SizeServesStandardCustom –
Hard Ice Cream, Yogurt or
No Sugar Added
Supreme – Neapolitan, Brownie or
3 Flavors
6" round6-8 $15.99 $18.99 $19.99
8" round12-15 $19.99 $23.99 $25.99
10" round15-20 $23.99 $28.99 $30.99
10 x 14 20-24 $31.99 $37.99 $40.99